In Father Jim McKeon's reflection on 'Why vote no to the Aboriginal Voice,' he discusses several reasons people might consider voting against the proposed Voice to Parliament in an upcoming referendum. He mentions that past consulted bodies, like NATSIC, have existed before, implying that this initiative may not be entirely novel. Additionally, he raises the valid concern that no institution, including The Voice, can fully represent every indigenous person, and suggests that certain outcomes, such as closing the gap in health and education, might be more effectively achieved at the state level.
However, Father McKeon delves deeper into a more subtle and insidious reason underlying some of the rational arguments against The Voice—envy. He explains how envy can manifest as a feeling of sadness when others seem to receive benefits or opportunities that one does not. He draws a parallel with the Gospel parable of laborers, where those who worked less received the same pay, causing envy among those who had worked longer. This downward envy, where people envy those who have less than themselves, might be subtly influencing some people's feelings and arguments against The Voice.
Father McKeon challenges the notion of envy and encourages a more generous and empathetic perspective, rooted in the teachings of the Gospel. He suggests that, while the issue of The Voice is complex and multi-faceted, it is essential to examine one's motivations, strive for generosity, and inform one's conscience when making decisions on such matters. Father McKeon acknowledges that the Bishops of Australia have not explicitly instructed how to vote but have encouraged Catholics to prayerfully consider the issue and align their vote with their understanding of God's calling.
In essence, Father Jim McKeon's reflection on voting against The Voice to Parliament presents both rational and emotional considerations, emphasizing the importance of examining one's motivations and being generous in one's attitudes and actions.
